Slipkid42 wrote:The voting process is broken. Maddux should've been unanimous. Morris was very good to great, he is borderline. Potential steroids usage aside, I don't think Biggio or Bagwell are HOF caliber players either. Yes, they were among the best players of their generation; but I feel the criteria should be slightly more slanted towards were they among the greatest players ever (which they were not). The Hall would become very crowded if they let that caliber of player in (and that would diminish it's austerity to me).
Have you actually looked at Biggio's and Bagwell's stats? The ONLY issue w/ regard to either of them is the steroids cloud. Otherwise they are both among the greatest ever at their positions. And you can look it up.