The slow, secret death of the electric guitar
Moderators: Jonicont, mark lynn, Maluca3, Tequila Cowboy, BigTom, CooleyGirl, olwiggum
- whatwouldcooleydo?
- Posts: 13693
- Joined: Sun Apr 25, 2010 3:44 pm
- Location: Desolation Row
- Contact:
The slow, secret death of the electric guitar
Son, this ain't a dream no more, it's the real thing
Re: The slow, secret death of the electric guitar
The author name checks the guitarists from Creed and Linkin Park as icons that should have kids running to the music store.
Please move this article to the WTF thread.
Please move this article to the WTF thread.
Beebs is not a ragey man
-
- Posts: 3989
- Joined: Sat Dec 17, 2011 6:34 pm
Re: The slow, secret death of the electric guitar
Beebs wrote:The author name checks the guitarists from Creed and Linkin Park as icons that should have kids running to the music store.
Please move this article to the WTF thread.
A single shot rifle and a one eyed dog.
Re: The slow, secret death of the electric guitar
Well he did say, “John Mayer? You don’t see a bunch of kids emulating John Mayer and listening to him and wanting to pick up a guitar because of him.”
So there is that.
So there is that.
By the time you drop them I'll be gone
And you'll be right where they fall the rest of your life
And you'll be right where they fall the rest of your life
-
- Posts: 414
- Joined: Thu Nov 03, 2011 3:12 pm
Re: The slow, secret death of the electric guitar
Rocky wrote:Well he did say, “John Mayer? You don’t see a bunch of kids emulating John Mayer and listening to him and wanting to pick up a guitar because of him.”
So there is that.
I have to disagree to an extent, there is a huge audience that searches for his tone the same way that folks of my era (40s) searched for the tones of guys like SRV and EVH (amongst others). Head over to pages like www.thegearpage.net and you will see it debated to a mind numbing extent.
IMHO the 3 big issues that are driving this decline are 1) the cost of guitars is at an all time high, for a Gibson Les Paul Standard or a Fender Stratocaster (American) you are well over $1000.
2) the quality of music, there just hasn't been a lot of guitar driven music in the mainstream for the last 20+ years
3) the want, kids don't have the same want to express themselves the same way that we did.
Re: The slow, secret death of the electric guitar
These people are wrongpsychobillycadillac wrote:there is a huge audience that searches for [Mayer's] tone
The law of diminishing returns. These guys make lots of cool videos. After this one I feel more comfortable that I'll probably never (again) own a legit Les Paul or Strat. This vid has a little more Tom Foolery than content but hang in there.psychobillycadillac wrote: the cost of guitars is at an all time high, for a Gibson Les Paul Standard or a Fender Stratocaster (American) you are well over $1000.
They are listening to the wrong music. F the mainstream. You'll never find the good stuff there.psychobillycadillac wrote: the quality of music, there just hasn't been a lot of guitar driven music in the mainstream for the last 20+ years
I feel your angle, but I find it hard to believe that generation X is fundamentally different form generation Y in Z way. Maybe kids have too many ways to express themselves? Rock and roll used to be the default of very few options for many of us. Maybe kids these days need more cool uncles and older brothers to help them find the rock amidst all the noise? Just thoughts.psychobillycadillac wrote:kids don't have the same want to express themselves the same way that we did.
Also, Here's Matt Pike (High on Fire, SLEEP) playing with some kids at the Portland, School Of Rock. The kid on drums is bad ass. (Also, Matt, a metal guitar demigod, plays a First Act)
wish I could embed it:
https://www.facebook.com/Weedian/videos ... 406002433/
Beebs is not a ragey man
- whatwouldcooleydo?
- Posts: 13693
- Joined: Sun Apr 25, 2010 3:44 pm
- Location: Desolation Row
- Contact:
Re: The slow, secret death of the electric guitar
the short attention span of kids today could also play in to all of this. Getting even merely decent at playing a guitar takes time
Son, this ain't a dream no more, it's the real thing
- whatwouldcooleydo?
- Posts: 13693
- Joined: Sun Apr 25, 2010 3:44 pm
- Location: Desolation Row
- Contact:
Re: The slow, secret death of the electric guitar
Also, proud to say I wouldn't recognize a Linkin Park song if it knocked at my door and asked if I've heard the good news
Son, this ain't a dream no more, it's the real thing
-
- Posts: 21794
- Joined: Fri Apr 02, 2010 10:52 am
- Location: Trying to stay focused on the righteous path
Re: The slow, secret death of the electric guitar
I very much doubt that kids these days have any less desire to express themselves than previous generations. In fact, if this goes in any direction, I'd say self-expression is a higher level goal or aspiration than it's ever been.
Electric guitar-based music is as far out of the mainstream as it's ever been during my lifetime. That means both less exposure to the instrument and its sounds and also that it's less cool to play guitar. Yes, beebs, there is plenty of guitar based music for those who want to find it but that's not the same as the impact of the pop cultural zeitgeist at any given moment.
Where's cotter when you need him? There's no doubt that learning to play guitar proficiently takes time, effort and commitment. The fact that almost any sound or series of sounds can be made w/ cheap and widely available hardware using easily learned software must be having an impact on the interest of young people in learning to play instruments. Add that to ersatz music forms like guitar hero and assumptions about short attention spans, immediate gratification, arguable preference for solo v. group activities and the like and it's no surprise that fewer kids are picking up instruments.
I would not be surprised if cost is a factor as well. There's been a general movement to "authenticity" in virtually every activity: Kids (at least suburban kids) don't play hoops unless there are fiberglass backboards or field sports unless the fields are superbly maintained w/ electronic scoreboards or any sport w/out cool uniforms, trained referees and coaches and all the fixins. I wouldn't be surprised if the same mindset applied to music so that only the "real thing" will do, and the real thing is pretty expensive if you're not willing to settle for traditional "starter level" or used instruments/equipment.
Electric guitar-based music is as far out of the mainstream as it's ever been during my lifetime. That means both less exposure to the instrument and its sounds and also that it's less cool to play guitar. Yes, beebs, there is plenty of guitar based music for those who want to find it but that's not the same as the impact of the pop cultural zeitgeist at any given moment.
Where's cotter when you need him? There's no doubt that learning to play guitar proficiently takes time, effort and commitment. The fact that almost any sound or series of sounds can be made w/ cheap and widely available hardware using easily learned software must be having an impact on the interest of young people in learning to play instruments. Add that to ersatz music forms like guitar hero and assumptions about short attention spans, immediate gratification, arguable preference for solo v. group activities and the like and it's no surprise that fewer kids are picking up instruments.
I would not be surprised if cost is a factor as well. There's been a general movement to "authenticity" in virtually every activity: Kids (at least suburban kids) don't play hoops unless there are fiberglass backboards or field sports unless the fields are superbly maintained w/ electronic scoreboards or any sport w/out cool uniforms, trained referees and coaches and all the fixins. I wouldn't be surprised if the same mindset applied to music so that only the "real thing" will do, and the real thing is pretty expensive if you're not willing to settle for traditional "starter level" or used instruments/equipment.
What used to be is gone and what ought to be ought not to be so hard
- Tequila Cowboy
- Site Admin
- Posts: 20230
- Joined: Mon Mar 29, 2010 6:12 pm
- Location: The Twilight Zone, along with everyone else
Re: The slow, secret death of the electric guitar
Playing Guitar Hero?beantownbubba wrote:Where's cotter when you need him?
Seriously though you make some solid points. I think it's more than that there are no guitar heroes, a lot of music doesn't have guitars. On top of that it's one more thing to compete with dozens of more things for budget and time. I have a hard time believing that the electric guitar is going to meet it's demise anytime soon though.
We call him Scooby Do, but Scooby doesn’t do. Scooby, is not involved
Re: The slow, secret death of the electric guitar
That's a movement towards "authenticity"? Sounds like a movement towards a bunch entitled little fucks. There's nothing "authentic" about any of that.beantownbubba wrote:There's been a general movement to "authenticity" in virtually every activity: Kids (at least suburban kids) don't play hoops unless there are fiberglass backboards or field sports unless the fields are superbly maintained w/ electronic scoreboards or any sport w/out cool uniforms, trained referees and coaches and all the fixins.
Off the lawn. Now.
Beebs is not a ragey man
-
- Posts: 21794
- Joined: Fri Apr 02, 2010 10:52 am
- Location: Trying to stay focused on the righteous path
Re: The slow, secret death of the electric guitar
Yeah. Authenticity was a really bad word choice there. Yikes!Beebs wrote:That's a movement towards "authenticity"? Sounds like a movement towards a bunch entitled little fucks. There's nothing "authentic" about any of that.beantownbubba wrote:There's been a general movement to "authenticity" in virtually every activity: Kids (at least suburban kids) don't play hoops unless there are fiberglass backboards or field sports unless the fields are superbly maintained w/ electronic scoreboards or any sport w/out cool uniforms, trained referees and coaches and all the fixins.
Off the lawn. Now.
What used to be is gone and what ought to be ought not to be so hard
- Tequila Cowboy
- Site Admin
- Posts: 20230
- Joined: Mon Mar 29, 2010 6:12 pm
- Location: The Twilight Zone, along with everyone else
Re: The slow, secret death of the electric guitar
Beebs wrote:That's a movement towards "authenticity"? Sounds like a movement towards a bunch entitled little fucks. There's nothing "authentic" about any of that.beantownbubba wrote:There's been a general movement to "authenticity" in virtually every activity: Kids (at least suburban kids) don't play hoops unless there are fiberglass backboards or field sports unless the fields are superbly maintained w/ electronic scoreboards or any sport w/out cool uniforms, trained referees and coaches and all the fixins.
Off the lawn. Now.
We call him Scooby Do, but Scooby doesn’t do. Scooby, is not involved
- sactochris
- Posts: 2581
- Joined: Sat Apr 24, 2010 6:47 pm
- Location: Orangevale, California
Re: The slow, secret death of the electric guitar
Perhaps someone should let Tad Kubler know.
Keep calm and have a cigar
Re: The slow, secret death of the electric guitar
Beebs has been extra grouchy lately. He must've run out of those Colorado edibles he brought back.Tequila Cowboy wrote:Beebs wrote:That's a movement towards "authenticity"? Sounds like a movement towards a bunch entitled little fucks. There's nothing "authentic" about any of that.beantownbubba wrote:There's been a general movement to "authenticity" in virtually every activity: Kids (at least suburban kids) don't play hoops unless there are fiberglass backboards or field sports unless the fields are superbly maintained w/ electronic scoreboards or any sport w/out cool uniforms, trained referees and coaches and all the fixins.
Off the lawn. Now.
If you don't run you rust
Re: The slow, secret death of the electric guitar
Disagree on several fronts. First, cost isn't really a factor - you can get decent guitars for pretty cheap nowadays. A decent acoustic can be bought new for like $75 and a decent electric set-up with a guitar and amp can be bought for around $200. And that doesn't even take Craigs List into account. Also, IMO all that authenticity stuff might matter to the parents but I don't think most teenagers are like that (at least not the ones I know).beantownbubba wrote: I would not be surprised if cost is a factor as well. There's been a general movement to "authenticity" in virtually every activity: Kids (at least suburban kids) don't play hoops unless there are fiberglass backboards or field sports unless the fields are superbly maintained w/ electronic scoreboards or any sport w/out cool uniforms, trained referees and coaches and all the fixins. I wouldn't be surprised if the same mindset applied to music so that only the "real thing" will do, and the real thing is pretty expensive if you're not willing to settle for traditional "starter level" or used instruments/equipment.
As others have alluded to above, I think the biggest problem has been the decline in guitar based music. Also there is a pretty steep learning curve for the guitar and I think that's become prohibitive since computers and apps have made it so easy to make music. Another thing I'd blame is that social media has become so pervasive for kids today that it takes up a huge amount of their free time that could be spent learning to play an instrument.
Anyway, interesting thread.
If you don't run you rust
- RolanK
- Posts: 3037
- Joined: Sun Oct 02, 2011 10:52 am
- Location: drivin' home early Sunday morning through Bakersfield
Re: The slow, secret death of the electric guitar
I am not surprised to read this, but still whenever I am near any form of public transport I see people of all ages (mostly boys/men though) carrying gig-bags. From what I understand the article refers statistics based on sales figures from the some of the larger companies in the market. Could it be that there is more turn-around of 2nd hand instruments via eBay etc? Most of my guitar-playing friends are primarily buying 2nd hand stuff. I own something like 8-9 guitars myself, only two were bought new from regular instrument stores, the rest are either built from parts, 2nd hand or custom guitars that would probably not show up in any statistics.
You also have youtube full of clips of kids with mad skills. You dont really have to take lessons anymore to learn basic (or even advanced) stuff anymore. Its all there. This was much less accessible when I tried to teach myself how to play back in the 80's.
Interesting to read about Gibson though. Robot tuners, and the horrible Firebird X launched a few years ago.Yuck!
You also have youtube full of clips of kids with mad skills. You dont really have to take lessons anymore to learn basic (or even advanced) stuff anymore. Its all there. This was much less accessible when I tried to teach myself how to play back in the 80's.
Interesting to read about Gibson though. Robot tuners, and the horrible Firebird X launched a few years ago.Yuck!
Fa-Fa-Fa-Fa-Fa
-
- Posts: 151
- Joined: Wed Nov 30, 2016 10:49 am
Re: The slow, secret death of the electric guitar
Breaking News "Guitar Bands Are On Their Way Out" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dick_Rowe