Man, this was tough, and I'm still not completely satisfied with it. But here we go:
1.
Felice Brothers - Life in the Dark
I went around and around before finally landing on Life in the Dark as my AOTY. This album is a full return to form for The Felice Brothers, mixing everything I love about them in a balance not heard since their self-titled album. The wry, clever, jangly tunes are offset by some of the most emotional, heartfelt songs Ian has ever written.
Top 3: Sell the House, Triumph '73, Diamond Bell
2. Wussy - Forever Sounds
After falling in love with this Cincinnati band after their Attica release, I expected big things from their follow up. At first, I was let down; it didn't immediately grab me the way Attica did. But I dug in, and as the album revealed itself, I grew to love it. I then saw them live earlier this year and was floored. This band deserves so much more popularity than they have.
Top 3: Donny's Death Scene, Hello I'm a Ghost, She's Killed Hundreds
3. Lucius - Good Grief
Lucius' sophomore album built on everything that was great about their debut (Wildewoman). Paired with legendary producer Bob Ezrin, this LA-via-Brooklyn quartet mixed soaring harmonies, pop fun, and sneaky good lyrics into one of the most fun albums of 2016.
Top 3 - Dusty Trails, Better Look Back, My Heart Got Caught on Your Sleeve
4. Radiohead - A Moon Shaped Pool
Welcome back, Radiohead! After the really uneven King of Limbs (and a multi-year break), one of my favorite bands of all time returned with a disquieting yet beautiful collection of songs that demands multiple listens.
Top 3 - Burn the Witch, The Numbers, Present Tense
5. Kanye West - The Life of Pablo
3DD's favorite rap genius had a bizarro year, capped with a sometimes brilliant, sometimes head-scratching album. The high points are very high, especially the album opener "Ultralight Beam," which features a gospel choir, Chance the Rapper, and some gorgeous singing. There are some other really great songs here, but there are some questionable inclusions, and with the release date constantly changing (and song edits being made literally hours before it was put out), it's not surprising that it sounds unpolished and unfinished. Hell, I still love it though.
Top 3 - Ultralight Beam, Famous, 30 Hours
6. Ray LaMontagne - Ouroboros
Montagne's "God Willin' and the Creek Don't Rise" was my AOTY a few years back, as Ray seemed to be peaking his mix of Stephen Stills folk, blue-eyed soul, and country roots. He followed with a Dan Auerbach produced exploration of 70's AM rock, and I wasn't sure what would come next. So when "Ouroboros" was released, I was completely blown away by the change in influences. This Jim James produced record drops the folk for a Pink-Floyd inspired rock record, with a few heavy Side A tracks that raise his sound to a new level. Montagne then toured the record with MMJ (minus James) as his backing band. If you didn't dig Ray's early records, its worth giving this one a shot just to hear how different it is.
Top 3: The Changing Man, While It Still Beats, Hey Man No Pressure
7. Wilco - Schmilco
It's the quieter, chiller half of "Star Wars"? Recorded in the same sessions, the vibe is definitely more laid back and spare, but the songwriting is tremendous (as always), as Tweedy continues to subtly evolve his songwriting from album to album. Great headphones album, as you can hear the intricacies in what seem, at first, like spare arrangements.
Top 3: Normal American Kids, Nope, Happiness
8. DBT - American Band
It's not the album we wanted, it was the one we needed. It's the first "concept" album DBT has written since DD, with scathing commentary on our fucked up country. But after the election, it became harder to listen to. Less enjoyable. I appreciate it for what it is, and really love album closer Baggage. I'll come back to this record soon, I just can't right now.
Top 3: Baggage, Ramon Casiano, Ever South
9. Dexateens - Teenage Hallelujah
This might have been my most anticipated album of the year, as Sunsphere is one of my favorite records of the past five years. While I don't think TH quite stacks up, there is a ton to love here. The Dexateens (along with DBT, Shovels & Rope, and several others) are among a growing group of Southern-based artists who are willing to discuss and expose the ugly side of rural-American culture. The 'teens do it mostly through humor, with great songs like Old Rebel, Shake n Bake Astrovan and Alabama Redneck. They even get a little Primus-esque on Jimmy John.
Top 3: Shake n Bake Astrovan, Old Rebel, Fellowship of the Saturday Night Brotherhood
10. Car Seat Headrest - Teens of Denial
I was an early adopter of this album, latching on like so many of us have with its rawness, its clear influences, its humor, and its honesty. Plus those hooks! Its like nothing else out there right now, and I can only hope to see them on tour soon.
Top 3: Destroyed By Hippie Powers, Cosmic Hero, The Ballad of Costa Concordia
11. Shovels & Rope - Little Seeds - S & R continue to explore their sound in a really good collection of songs. Nothing especially ground breaking here, but if you're a fan, there's a lot to like.
12. A Tribe Called Quest - We Got it From Here…Thank You 4 Your Service - A brilliant final album from a rap group that most of us thought had already made their final album (years and years ago). This record was like a shot in the arm at the end of the year.
13. Claypool Lennon Delirium - The Monolith of Phobos - Born from a tour where Lennon's band (Ghost of a Saber Toothed Tiger) opened for Primus, this album was the result of a burst of creativity fueled over a few days (and a lot of edibles). Lennon and Claypool play all the instruments, and the result is typical Claypool weirdness made richer and more melodic through Lennon's psychedelic, intricately melodic tendencies.
14. Run the Jewels - RTJ3 - Scheduled for mid-January, this album was dropped on Christmas (for free!) and squeezes onto the 2016 list. Run the Jewels is a rarity in today's hip hop landscape: an actual group that trades lines and collaborates. RTJ is fiercely political, and take no prisoners lyrically. El-P has developed a signature production sound that sometimes sounds a bit "samey", but is identifiable as RTJ.
15. Quilt - Plaza - These psychedelic songsters went back to their first songs and re-recorded them for this year's album. The band sounds like they're straight out of the late 60's/early 70's, and the dreamy hooks push my buttons.
16. Black Mountain - IV - This was my introduction to this band, and the first song really grabbed me. As I've dug through the back catalog, I've found some earlier records I like better, but I'm glad to have found this band.
17. Dr. Dog - Psychedelic Swamp - Like Quilt, Dr. Dog returned to early band recordings and reworked and rerecorded them. They even brought back an original member (who hasn't been in the group in years) to sing a song.
18. Hamilton Mixtape - The phenomenon that was Hamilton on Broadway created a lot of fans among established rap and R&B artists alike. SO Hamilton creator Lin-Manuel Miranda curated a mixtape of covers, work-upped demos, and original songs "inspired" by the musical by artists like Nas, Sia, Queen Latifah, John Legend, and Chance the Rapper. The results aren't always great, but there are some shining moments, especially among the originals.
19. Chance the Rapper - Coloring Book - Chicago MC (and Kanye protege) Chance dropped his first album and introduced himself as an up and coming star. The duality of the hop hop thing is addressed, with equal parts religious spirituality and braggadocios party life.
20. Amanda Shires - My Piece of Land - Shires has a unique voice in the Americana scene, and while I didn't quite like this one as much as her last release, I think what she does is great. I've missed seeing her live a few times, and plan to fix that ASAP.
21. Conor Oberst - Ruminations - Oberst strips it down, with most songs accompanied by just a guitar or a piano. He's still floating a bit in his post-Bright Eyes career, but he's still a prolific songwriter.
22. Kendrick Lamar - Untitled Unmastered - An EP of outtakes from To Pimp a Butterfly and other sessions, these songs are a mostly good, but disjointed group of hip hop. Even Kendrick's leftovers outshine most hip hop out there.
23. Handsome Family - Unseen - I heard them interviewed on NPR and gave the album a shot. It's a mood record, with slower tempos, lilting arrangements, and some sublime pedal steel.
24. Carl Broemel - 4th of July - My Morning Jacket's lead guitarist releases another solo record, and while it starts out very strong, it sort of wanes by the end. The early songs are really great, and hopefully one might make its way into the MMJ setlists.
25. John Paul White - Beulah - Former Civil Wars songwriter makes some gorgeous songs.