The Beatle's Let It Be
John Prine Self Titled..
Bob Dylan's Blood on the Tracks, and New Morning
Johnny Cash Man In Black

after a quick scan, it appears that kinks/lola vs and misfits did not get enough love.

shame on us.

dime in the gutter wrote:after a quick scan, it appears that kinks/lola vs and misfits did not get enough love.

shame on us.

Even more egregious when you consider the lack of Kinks on your initial "one album per band" list.

cortez the killer wrote:

dime in the gutter wrote:after a quick scan, it appears that kinks/lola vs and misfits did not get enough love.

shame on us.

Even more egregious when you consider the lack of Kinks on your initial "one album per band" list.

newman!

2015 reboot edition:

1. Sticky Fingers/The Rolling Stones
2. Physical Graffiti/Led Zeppelin
3. Darkness on the Edge of Town/Bruce Springsteen
4. Tonight's the Night/Neil Young
5. Exile on Main Street/The Rolling Stones

6. Honky Tonk Heroes/Waylon Jennings
7. Zuma/Neil Young & Crazy Horse
8. #1 Record/Big Star
9. Animals/Pink Floyd
10. Muswell Hillbillies/The Kinks

11. After the Gold Rush/Neil Young
12. On the Beach/Neil Young
13. Old No. 1/Guy Clark
14. Time Fades Away/Neil Young
15. Led Zeppelin IV/Led Zeppelin

16. Planet Waves/Bob Dylan
17. Lola Versus Powerman & The Moneygoround/The Kinks
18. Houses of the Holy/Led Zeppelin
19. Some Girls/The Rolling Stones
20. Born to Run/Bruce Springsteen

21. ¡Viva Terlingua!/Jerry Jeff Walker
22. Can't Buy a Thrill/Steely Dan
23. Cosmo's Factory/Creedence Clearwater Revival
24. Radio City/Big Star
25. Wish You Were Here/Pink Floyd

Cortez, is this hindsight or the actual albums I was listening to in the 70's which I loved at that time? If its the latter, then

Beatles, Blue Album
Beatles, Red Album
Beatles, White Album (played in backwards many times)
Led Zepplin IV
Yes, Fragile
Yes, Yessongs
Kiss, Alive
Beatles, Sargent Pepper
Beatels, Meet the Beatles
Aerosmith, Rocks
Aerosmith, Toys in the Attick
Aerosmith, the one with Dream On and Mama Kin
Queen, Night at the Opera
Led Zep, II
Led Zep, Physical Graffitti
Kiss, Destroyer
Led Zep, I
Beatles, Revolver
Bad Company, Running with the Pack
Kiss, Rock n Roll Over
Yes, I forgot the name of the ablum, but with Perpetual Change
Yes, Close to the Edge
Bad Company, Bad Co
Van Morrison, Moon Dance
Barry Manilow, Live (I shit you not, the part with the commercial jingles which he wrote was awsome at the time, don't tell Gene Simmons)
Jimi Hendrix, Electric Ladyland
Jimi Hendrix, Axis Bold as Love
Joe Pass, Virtuoso 2
Paul McCartney, Band on the Run

cortez the killer wrote:Pulling out an all-time great 3DD thread. It's got:

Rudeness
Ball busting
List making
Genre defining
Pedanticism
Obsessing over musical minutiae
70's music
Punk Rock
Dad Rock
Noses getting bent outta shape

I also believe there is some evidence of Zip's infamous banning in there.

not to mention all 6 steely dan albums and not a single one by Rory Gallagher

GG - Born in '73, I didn't have the pleasure of experiencing these records in the moment. My list is 100% hindsight, and my latest list is an update on my original post from May 2010.

Dean wrote:

cortez the killer wrote:Pulling out an all-time great 3DD thread. It's got:

Rudeness
Ball busting
List making
Genre defining
Pedanticism
Obsessing over musical minutiae
70's music
Punk Rock
Dad Rock
Noses getting bent outta shape

I also believe there is some evidence of Zip's infamous banning in there.

not to mention all 6 steely dan albums and not a single one by Rory Gallagher

I'm guessing this is the only place something like that would happen. You can always affect the latter.

No Steve Miller Band
No Goodbye Yellow Brick Road
No Boston

(unless I missed them)

cortez the killer wrote:GG - Born in '73, I didn't have the pleasure of experiencing these records in the moment. My list is 100% hindsight, and my latest list is an update on my original post from May 2010.

I was born 1962, I'm actually the same age as the New York Mets. Looking at your list, I probably could have included,

Pink Floyd, Wish you Here and Dark Side
Bruce Springsteen, Greetings from Asbury Park and Darkness at the Edge of Town, and, yes, Born to Run, but I claimed to love Greetings at the time.

My hindsight list would be a lot different. I don't think I joined until Jan 2011 so I missed out on the begining of this post. Probably for the best, I wouldn't have been able to handle it back then.

Dean wrote:No Steve Miller Band
No Goodbye Yellow Brick Road
No Boston

(unless I missed them)

Can't speak for all the posters, but I'm pretty sure that's intentional.

beantownbubba wrote:

Dean wrote:No Steve Miller Band
No Goodbye Yellow Brick Road
No Boston

(unless I missed them)

Can't speak for all the posters, but I'm pretty sure that's intentional.

Har!

My original list stands up pretty well.

Exile on Main St.- Rolling Stones
London Calling- The Clash
Quadrophenia- the Who
Songs in the Key of Life- Stevie Wonder
Houses of the Holy- Led Zeppelin
Blood On the Tracks- Dylan
Stage Fright- The Band
My Aim Is True- Elvis Costello
A Nod is as Good as a Wink..To a Blind Horse- Faces
American Beauty- Grateful Dead

I'll add to it though:

Elton John- Goodbye Yellow Brick Road
Joe Jackson- Look Sharp
The Jam- All Mod Cons
Cheap Trick- Heaven Tonight
Jackson Browne- Running on Empty
Blue Oyster Cult- Agents of Fortune
Ramones- Rocket To Russia
Big Star- #1 Record
Marvin Gaye- What's Going On?
Eddie Hinton- Letters From Mississippi

I'm sure my list would be different now but I'm not sure it would be any better. But I am shocked that I left out Shoot Out the Lights.

While I'm glad that I at least remembered to include Bowie as an "honorable mention" he really does have to be on any list of the best 70s albums. In retrospect it does seem odd to have a list of 70's albums w/out Elton John on it but there's not a single album of his that I love w/out qualification nor am I sure what I'd take out in order to have him represented. In some moods, I might also try to sneak any early Chicago album on there.

As an observation w/out any real point behind it, I'm pretty sure there's over a 100 million in album sales represented by a mere 5 artists not included on my list:

Elton John
Billy Joel
Chicago
Peter Frampton
Boston

dime in the gutter wrote:

Zip City wrote:i'm now convinced that dime has zero idea what punk rock is

loud, beligerent, aggressive, anti-"the man", anti-social, angry, obnoxious music played with emotion, energy and defiant swagger.

just my opinion.

Thanks to Cortez for digging up this thread. This definition of punk rock from the 2010 dime is note perfect. Bravo,

beantownbubba wrote: As an observation w/out any real point behind it, I'm pretty sure there's over a 100 million in album sales represented by a mere 5 artists not included on my list:

Elton John
Billy Joel
Chicago
Peter Frampton
Boston

Talk about setting up a free shot at an empty net Bubba!!

But I'm in enough trouble around these parts

The name of the thread is favorite albums not critically acclaimed landmark albums of the 70's. Who gives a fuck if there are 6 Steely Dan records on someone's list? Hell I believe I have the first two Dire Straits records on my list and I know that sends a certain Scottish snob into a tizzy.

Gator McKlusky wrote:The name of the thread is favorite albums not critically acclaimed landmark albums of the 70's. Who gives a fuck if there are 6 Steely Dan records on someone's list? Hell I believe I have the first two Dire Straits records on my list and I know that sends a certain Scottish snob into a tizzy.

Crank that Making Movies and put on a damned red headband in solidarity!! I'll join ya brotha.

Gator McKlusky wrote:The name of the thread is favorite albums not critically acclaimed landmark albums of the 70's. Who gives a fuck if there are 6 Steely Dan records on someone's list? Hell I believe I have the first two Dire Straits records on my list and I know that sends a certain Scottish snob into a tizzy.

I think you'll find I'm so laid back I'm horizontal about the blandness that oozes out of Mark Knopflers guitar - it's certain other posters on here whose blood pressure goes through the roof at anybody who rails against their musical heroes

linkous wrote:

Gator McKlusky wrote:The name of the thread is favorite albums not critically acclaimed landmark albums of the 70's. Who gives a fuck if there are 6 Steely Dan records on someone's list? Hell I believe I have the first two Dire Straits records on my list and I know that sends a certain Scottish snob into a tizzy.

I think you'll find I'm so laid back I'm horizontal about the blandness that oozes out of Mark Knopflers guitar - it's certain other posters on here whose blood pressure goes through the roof at anybody who rails against their musical heroes

Still managed to work in a Dire Straits insult. KG, come back! I might have someone else for you to attack!

linkous wrote:I think you'll find I'm so laid back I'm horizontal about the blandness that oozes out of Mark Knopflers guitar - it's certain other posters on here whose blood pressure goes through the roof at anybody who rails against their musical heroes

No blood pressure problems here. In my youth I might have given a fuck but as I'm deep in my dotage I find that my supply of fucks is limited and sadly defending Dire Straits is not worth one.

Tequila Cowboy wrote:

linkous wrote:I think you'll find I'm so laid back I'm horizontal about the blandness that oozes out of Mark Knopflers guitar - it's certain other posters on here whose blood pressure goes through the roof at anybody who rails against their musical heroes

No blood pressure problems here. In my youth I might have given a fuck but as I'm deep in my dotage I find that my supply of fucks is limited and sadly defending Dire Straits is not worth one.

Yeah, you're not one who is at risk of blood pressure problems - they know who they are

Never said anyone particular person had all 6 steely dan albums on their list, just found i interesting that all 6 were represented collectively while other artists were omitted altogether. Again, collectively. If someone is too insecure in themselves to admit they loved Goodbye Yellow Brick Road enough to list it in their top 100, well, that's on them.

I love Dire Straits and Mark Knopler's guitar tone too.

Now back to your regularly scheduled programming, Incessant List-making

Dean wrote: Incessant List-making

It's what we do.

I agree on Goodbye Yellow Brick Road btw and added it it to my list.

Tequila Cowboy wrote:

Dean wrote: Incessant List-making

It's what we do.

I agree on Goodbye Yellow Brick Road btw and added it it to my list.

No kidding. Seems that the "best of" lists end up being "personal favorites", so why not the other way around. LOL.

Dean wrote:

Tequila Cowboy wrote:

Dean wrote: Incessant List-making

It's what we do.

I agree on Goodbye Yellow Brick Road btw and added it it to my list.

No kidding. Seems that the "best of" lists end up being "personal favorites", so why not the other way around. LOL.

It's a struggle. I've mostly given up. Now we throw stuff around and argue and occasionally it can be entertaining. Other times panties get bunched. Que sera sera.

It's a struggle. I've mostly given up. Now we throw stuff around and argue and occasionally it can be entertaining. Other times panties get bunched. Que sera sera.

not surprising considering how seriously we all take our love of music.

Count me squarely in the " not my thing but I understand the appeal" camp (on most artists). Nothing irritates me as much as not being able (or willing) to separate taste from talent

Dean wrote:

cortez the killer wrote:Pulling out an all-time great 3DD thread. It's got:

Rudeness
Ball busting
List making
Genre defining
Pedanticism
Obsessing over musical minutiae
70's music
Punk Rock
Dad Rock
Noses getting bent outta shape

I also believe there is some evidence of Zip's infamous banning in there.

not to mention all 6 steely dan albums and not a single one by Rory Gallagher

seems right to me. at least the first 5, anyway.