Iowan wrote:Shakespeare wrote:Duke Silver wrote:The more shitty albums they release, the better these middle period albums start to sound.
i'm a bigger latter day weezer apologist than most, but ive always included green and maladroit in the "classic" run. Neither one is anywhere near bad. green is just a nice breezy pop album and maladroit is a (mostly) successful heavy metal tribute. blue and pinkerton are significantly better than both, but the drop off isnt as big as some might say. or at least not yet
make believe is the real point where it gets rough, but i still find good stuff in their new releases. the red album is pretty solid overall, with some experiments that worked and some admirable failures, and there's a great album hidden among make believe, hurley and raditude. but that doesnt mean there arent total embarrassments too.
im obviously clouded a bit by nostalgia, but i havent written the band off yet.
Make Believe is where I stopped caring about Weezer, but I've found at least one or two songs on all of the recent albums that was good to great. "(If You're Wondering If I Want You To) I Want You To" is a damn near perfect throwaway pop song.
There's just so much complete and utter shit on those albums that I can't too excited about a new Weezer release, or even contemplate paying to see them live. A rousing rendition of "In The Mall" just isn't gonna cut it.
this is fair. i just get a bit peeved when people write off the entirety of their post maladroit catalogue. a few songs in there ("the angel and the one" comes to mind immediately. i wish it had an even bigger "only in dreams" style climax, but it's a hell of a song) are among my all time weezer favorites.
the other thing i dont quite get about modern day weezer criticism is that they've always written "throwaway pop songs," and theres always been fairly ridiculous and juvenile content. the older dumb pop songs are objectively better, but its not like rivers suddenly flipped a switch and decided to write stuff about malls or whatever geek culture thing he'll sing about next. i think a lot of it is that the older weezer fanbase grew up, but rivers' writing kinda didn't, and the endearing charm of stuff like buddy holly and the sweater song wore off. or it's just less genuine coming from a 40 year old than a 20 year old. i dont know, their/his career arc is really interesting to me for some reason. probably why i still get at least a bit excited to sort through the inevitable turds to find the good songs.
at this point im probably most interested in getting a few more volumes of rivers'
alone series. those have had some really great stuff.
@ Duke: i wasn't listening to weezer when green/maladroit came out, but i did hear them after having and loving blue and pinkerton for a while, and i just didn't see the huge drop in quality. i can understand being disappointed (especially the insanely simple green album coming out after the emotional heaviness of pinkerton) but i wasnt. one of the benefits of being a few years behind, i guess.
and seconded on the greg dulli binge. i'll be seeing the afghan whigs on friday and i haven't played those records in a while. cant wait to see them!